ECAS7

Panels

(P098)

Gender, body politics and humanitarian fields in Africa

Location KH105
Date and Start Time 01 July, 2017 at 14:00

Convenors

Giovanna Cavatorta (University of Roma Tre) email
Michela Fusaschi (University of Rome Three) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

In the field of the anthropology of humanitarian governmentalities, this panel aims to discuss researches on gender policies and body politics in Africa.

Long Abstract

Humanitarian projects promoting biopolitics of the body and aimed at enforcing women's and gender rights (e.g. campaigns for the abandonment of the so-called "FGM/C" practices, promoting sexual health, targeting lgbt and sexworker groups, etc.) are highly spread in Africa challenging local sex/gender systems. In these fields transnational, governmental and grassroots social dynamics articulate with each other and different representations of gender violence and empowerment circulate. We propose to consider these projects as social arenas in which moral economies are elaborated and negotiated and relations of power among different gendered subjectivities are defined and deployed.

The overall objective of this panel is to contribute to a critical anthropology of human rights, gender and body politics in the domain of humanitarian governmentalities in Africa. We seek contributions offering a strong analysis of both sited discourse and social practices in order to gain anthropological insights into the complex moral, social and political stakes.

Which representations of healthiness and pleasure are allowed to be expressed? Which "traditional" and "modern" gendered bodies are produced and how are they legitimized? How to disclose neocolonialist approaches underlying neoliberal biopolitics? When and which positioned definitions of structural violence, gender violence and empowerment emerge? Considering these projects in terms of politics of redistribution, what about extraversion in this sense? These and other questions could be addressed.

This panel welcomes papers in English and French.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

La prise en compte du genre dans la réponse humanitaire au Cameroun: externalisation des aspirations sociales d'une population en contexte d'urgence

Author: Honoré Mimche (IFORD)  email

Short Abstract

Au les actions humanitaires menées en faveur ds réfugiés concernent les problèmes de santé sexuelle, la lutte contre les violences sexuelles et les violences basées sur le genre et les pratiques sociales néfastes. Cet article analyse les logiques des résistances qui les sous-tendent.

Long Abstract

Depuis quelques années, le Cameroun fait face à un afflux massif de réfugiés aujourd'hui installés dans plusieurs régions du pays. Ceux-ci proviennent de RCA et du Nigéria principalement. POur y faire face, les agences humanitaires ont développés plusieurs interventions et depuis quelques temps la question de la prise en compte des besoins spécifiques des femmes les ont conduit à intriduire un paquet d'activités en faveur des femmes et filles. Celles ci concernent notamment les problèmes de santé sexuelle, la lutte contre les violences sexuelles et les violences basées sur le genre et les pratiques sociales néfastes, etc. La mise en oeuvre de ces interventions ne se fait pas sans parfois des réticences socioculturelles liées à la conception que les populations ont de ces orientations souvent considérées comme exogènes à leurs besoins spécifiques. Cette proposition tente d'analyser ces formes de résistances à partir d'une analyse des logiques culturelles qui les sous-tendent. Il sagit de voir comment les populations se construisent ces interventions souvent très peu culturellement ancrées dans les habitudes

NGOs and female circumcision in Egypt. An anthropological enquiry

Author: Elsa Mescoli (Universite de Liege)  email

Short Abstract

This paper aims at presenting some ethnographic data stemmed from a research conducted in Egypt concerning humanitarian discourse and practice around female circumcision. It will show the role that this plays on the definition of female body and how women interact with this very same definition.

Long Abstract

In 1994, during the International Conference on Population and Development convened by the United Nations in Cairo, a shocking video was shown, recorded by CNN and depicting the circumcision of a ten-year-old child living in the same city. Discourses around female circumcision were not new to Egypt or to the international community, but the video, a new episode in a recurrent scandal, enhanced the 'war against bad government' (Foucault 2003:38) - a war fought with ideological weapons produced by various forms of expert knowledge, among which were medical and feminist views. The assignment of value to the 'integrity' of the female body and to women's freedom of choice, both designed according to western canons, led to different actions to 'save' Egyptian women. In this context, development agencies fostered a widespread representation of the 'victim', the woman's mutilated body. Such representation is functional to establishing programmes that do not guarantee freedom of choice but rather require adherence to another female model, one that defines the 'modern' woman.

My paper, based on ethnographic experience, highlights the complexity of these dynamics and the role played by humanitarianism within them. The female body becomes the arena in which local and international economic powers operate, disregarding a real understanding of the practice, its meanings and its eventual change.

Gender, Biopolitics, and Temporal Interventions in Ugandan "Girls' Empowerment" NGOs

Author: Erin Moore (Northwestern University)  email

Short Abstract

This paper critically analyzes the logics of “global girls’ empowerment” in Ugandan NGOs, revealing them as biopolitical projects that smuggle in neocolonial assumptions about young women’s time, labor, and sexuality.

Long Abstract

In the past decade, efforts to control population growth in the global South have taken new face in the global movement to "empower" adolescent girls. Demographers and development experts alike have increasingly focused on early interventions into the female life course in order to delay and reduce pregnancies, interventions they project will help stem the costs of overpopulation and thereby stimulate macroeconomic growth. In Uganda, the world's "youngest" country with more than 78% of the population below the age of 30, population control is an ever-increasing concern. There, development practitioners conducting "girls' empowerment" interventions interpret this global focus on the adolescent girl through interventions that aim to delay the onset of a young woman's reproductive life by reforming her everyday temporality. In particular, Ugandan "girls' empowerment" practitioners seek to curb pregnancies by occupying girls' time with entrepreneurial labor. Officials voiced a fear that when young women remain "idle," they transact sex in order to earn money, or, more simply, because they are bored. These discourses and social practices, which circulate across transnational, national, and local scales, tie young women's everyday temporalities to promiscuity, population control, and to global developmentalist logics. This paper critically analyzes these logics, revealing them as biopolitical projects that smuggle in neocolonial assumptions about young women's time, labor, and sexuality.

Assuming the Value of Virginity: Fitting Maasai Female Genital Cutting into Transnational Narratives

Author: Mary-Anne Decatur (SOAS)  email

Short Abstract

Drawing on fifteen months of fieldwork, this paper explores how efforts to end 'FGM' practices in Maasai communities around the Kilimanjaro region of Tanzania are entangled with various actors' assumptions and assertions about the desirability of women's virginity and sexual fidelity.

Long Abstract

In Tanzania's Kilimanjaro region, NGO employees campaigning for the abandonment of 'FGM' predominantly identify as Chagga and are based around urban Moshi, while the primary targets of their interventions are comparatively rural and less affluent Maasai people. Female genital cutting practices largely ended in Chagga communities decades ago, but continue to be the norm in these Maasai communities. Drawing on fifteen months of fieldwork, this paper explores how local efforts to end FGM are entangled with people's assumptions and assertions about the desirability of women's virginity and sexual fidelity. Maasai initiation into adulthood, emurata, involves genital cutting for both women and men. For many, this initiation remains integral to their Maasai identity, personhood, and religious relationship with the deity Eng'ai. Premarital sex is expected, extramarital sex is tolerated, and paternity is recognized in terms of marriage rather than biology. Recent increases in urban migration, however, have for some increased the importance ascribed to biological kinship. Christianity has played a pivotal role in Maasai discourses supporting an end to women's emurata. Maasai Christians advocating against women's emurata have in certain cases encouraged the 'modern' expectation of premarital virginity and discouraged the commonplace practice of child adoption. Non-Maasai NGO employees working around Kilimanjaro generally assume virginity is a traditional requirement for Maasai marriage. This assumption likely stems partly from the historical expectation of virginity prior to Chagga marriage as well as broader transnational discourses which present attempts to ensure virginity and prevent adultery as key reasons for the continuation of FGM procedures.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.