ECAS7

Panels

(P134)

Urban scenographies of political power in Africa before 1900 (double panel)

Location KH104
Date and Start Time 30 June, 2017 at 14:00

Convenors

Roberto Zaugg (Université de Lausanne) email
Clélia Coret (Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne / Institut des Mondes Africains) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

This panel focusses on African cities before 1900, examining through an interdisciplinary approach how political power is materially embodied and symbolically staged in the urban space through a variety of architectural interventions, visual representations, discourses and cultural practices.

Long Abstract

Well before the emergence of contemporary capitals and metropolitan areas, Africa experienced a vast array of urban forms. City-States as well as capitals and other major centres of empires and kingdoms constitute promising fields of inquiry to examine the relations between urban spaces and the exercise of power in earlier periods. Political powers perform regulative functions with regard to social interactions, economic transactions as well as to cultural and religious life. Hence, they contribute to shape cities in both material and symbolic terms. At the same time, political elites tend to use urban spaces to stage themselves and to assert their legitimacy, deploying architectural interventions, visual representations, discourses and ritual/ceremonial practices. Our panel will focus on cities in continental and insular Africa prior to 1900 in order to explore scenographies of political power. By investigating written, oral, archaeological, visual and artistic sources and discussing both interregional and intercontinental exchanges, it will examine the embodiment of political power in places such as royal courts, religious buildings, public squares, markets, etc. Thereby, the panel will tackle the strategies enacted to represent - or to contest - the legitimacy and continuity of social order in urban contexts which are structurally characterized by economic and migratory dynamics fuelling (potentially destabilizing) processes of social change. In this sense, it aims at analysing the stratified semantics of urban landscapes as results of conflicts and negotiations between a multiplicity of social groups and institutional actors.

Discussant: Prof. Gérard Chouin (College of William & Mary, Williamsburg VA)

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

What do we really know about Medieval Ife as an urban centre? Some thoughts on archaeological data and historical imagination

Author: Gérard Chouin (College Of William & Mary)  email

Short Abstract

In this paper, I attempt a critical study of our shared scientific consciousness about the urban nature of the famous medieval site of Ife, in Nigeria. I attempt to sort out archaeologically demonstrated facts and anachronistic analogical projections of more recent Yoruba urban reality.

Long Abstract

Ife is an exception in the historiography of Medieval West Africa, with an extensive literature about this city during the first half of the second millennium CE. This rich historiography is based on three categories of sources: the archaeological record, an outstanding selection of the material record of ancient Ife usually referred to as 'art' and a large corpus of oral traditions. After about 100 years of research on Ife, the city has taken its place on our shelves and in our imagination, as a walled urban centre of a medieval polity occupying a strategic location on the northern edge of the guinea forest and as an island of scholarship in an otherwise little known medieval world in the Guinea belt. In this paper, I critically reflect on the part of this scholarship that deals with the urban nature, characteristics and chronology of medieval Ife. What do we think we know about Ife as a settlement, and how did such knowledge become part of our shared scientific consciousness? How much of this knowledge is anchored in a reasonable interpretation of the archaeological record? How much of it may, however, be no more than an analogical projection of elements of the early modern and 19th century Yoruba urban landscape onto a medieval context? Such a reflection is, in part, emerging from new archaeological work conducted in 2015, 2016 and 2017 at Ita Yemoo and other sites at the cradle of the Yoruba world.

Routes of Red Coral. Intercontinental Trade and the Staging of Royal Power in the Kingdom of Benin since the late 15th century

Author: Roberto Zaugg (Université de Lausanne)  email

Short Abstract

By focusing on the trade of Mediterranean coral beads to Atlantic Africa and the symbolic meanings associated to these objects in the Kingdom of Benin, this paper explores royal courts as laboratories of cosmopolite entanglements and cultural appropriations.

Long Abstract

Starting in the 15th century, the emergence of intercontinental economic exchanges between European companies and African elites as well as the consolidation of the continent's coastal regions as contact zones impacted on the material cultures and the patterns of elite consumption of Atlantic Africa. As in other parts of the world, royal courts were laboratories of the entangled process of aesthetic change brought about by the intensification of global trade: as physically circumscribed spaces where political power is staged through formalised ceremonial codes and is associated with the display of artefacts embodying wealth and distinction, they constitute significant objects to study cross-cultural exchanges.

My paper will explore this field by focussing on the trade of red coral beads to Atlantic Africa and on the transformative appropriation of these objects at the court of Benin. In the Euro-Mediterranean space, coral had been used for centuries to make protective amulets, devotional objects (Christian rosaries, Jewish Torah pointers, Islamic misbaha), artistic artefacts and even medicines. And - since antiquity - it had been exported to various Asian regions. In many aspects, coral was already a multi-layered thing when Portuguese vessels started trading it to Atlantic Africa, where (other kinds of) beads often already held important symbolic functions and where the imported red beads were charged with new meanings. Mediterranean coral acquired a particularly prominent position in the Kingdom of Benin, where it was associated with the monarch (Oba) and his dignitaries and where it became an object of sumptuary norms, mythological traditions, ritual practices and art.

Yoruba Cities and Civil Wars: A Reevaluation of Refugee Absorption and Intergroup Relations in Nineteenth Century Yorubaland

Author: Akanmu Adebayo (Kennesaw State University)  email

Short Abstract

The paper examines the changes wrought on Yoruba cities by 19th century wars. It asks: How did wars affect existing cities? How did city planning and architecture change? What changes did refugee movement and resettlement create? What can present refugee crisis learn from Yoruba cities' responses?

Long Abstract

The Yoruba have a strong preference for city life; it is an integral part of their myths and religion. Cities were the location for periodic and annual traditional religious observances and, subsequently, the zone of activities for the spread of Islam and Christianity. In the 19th century, however, Yoruba civil wars put this system under pressure. With the outbreak and spread of wars, refugees and brigands fell on existing villages and towns, inaugurating a chain reaction. While the Yoruba civil wars have received scholarly attention, the changes wrought on cityscapes and city-life have not. Several cities (Owu, Old Oyo, Iwere, etc.) were razed by war. New cities (New Oyo, Ibadan, Abeokuta) emerged and thrived but some, like Ijaye, collapsed shortly after founding. Warlords and brigands, fleeing from their own towns, seized other towns and forced reigning monarchs to make far-reaching administrative and economic concessions. Thus, cities like Ilorin, Iwo, Ile-Ife, Ogbomosho, Ede, and Osogbo, made adjustments to accommodate the influx of refugees and migrants. Towns located along the trade routes, such as Lagos, Ijebu-Ode, and Ondo, also experienced changes. This paper examines political, economic, social, and other changes experienced by these Yoruba towns. It discusses the impact on safety and security, land tenure and use, settlement patterns, architecture, town planning, intergroup relations, indigene-migrant dichotomies, and chieftaincy disputes. Since the city was the center of a kingdom over which a crowned monarch (oba alade) reigned, the paper examines how the wars impacted kingship traditions, legitimacy, power, and seniority among Yoruba obas.

Ḥamdallāhi, a City in Praise of God

Author: Mauro Nobili (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)  email

Short Abstract

My paper focuses on Ḥamdallāhi from a symbolic and a pragmatic point of view. Symbolic as the city was built to embody the ideal Islamic city. At the same time, Ḥamdallāhi was built to control the nomadic life of the Fulani and put them under the centralized control of the newly emerged caliphate.

Long Abstract

In 1818, the Muslim reformer Aḥmad Lobbo defeated a coalition of Bambara and Fulani soldiers and established a new West African caliphate, in today's Republic of Mali. Among the first decisions he took was the foundation of a new capital city: Ḥamdallāhi - from the Arabic "Praise be to God." The establishment of Ḥamdallāhi reflects the need of the new ruler to settle in a city that had no ties with previous political powers of the region, but also set the norm for a large-scale operation of sedentarization of Fulani nomads, who composed the largest part of Aḥmad Lobbo's supporters. The creation of new urban spaces is peculiar of many of the so-called 19th-century African jihads, such as Sokoto (founded by 'Uthmān b. Fūdī) and Omdurman (founded by the Sudanese Mahdi) among others. However, scholars have so-far neglected such cities, except for Omdurman that is the subject of a monographic study by Robert Kramer (Holy City on the Nile: Omdurman during the Mahdiyya, 1885-1898. Princeton, N.J.: Markus Weiner, 2010). This paper aims at analyzing Ḥamdallāhi from both a symbolic as well as a pragmatic point of view. Symbolic as the city was built to embody the ideal Islamic city, where the tenets of the religion could be performed at their best. At the same time, Ḥamdallāhi was built for pragmatic reasons, i.e. the need to control the nomadic life of the Fulani and put them under the centralized control of the newly emerged caliphate.

The city, the palace, and the mosque. Asserting political legitimacy through urban re-foundation on the nineteenth-century Swahili coast

Author: Clélia Coret (Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne / Institut des Mondes Africains)  email

Short Abstract

By focusing on the re-foundation of a city on the nineteenth-century East African coast, this paper examines how political rulers appropriated urban spaces in order assert legitimacy.

Long Abstract

City-states emerged early on the East African (or Swahili) littoral. Acting as an interface between the sea and the mainland, the cities' elites managed to channel the sources of power and prestige connected to trade, Islam and urban life. Archaeological remains of palaces, mosques and patrician stone houses built along the coast - from Kilwa in the south to Pate in the north - provide impressive evidence on this behalf. During the nineteenth century, the cities of the Lamu archipelago on the northern Swahili coast witnessed important political conflicts. In their attempt to gain control over the littoral, the Omanis forced a part of the dynastic clan of Pate to leave their city. Fleeing to the adjacent mainland, in 1862 the former rulers of Pate founded a new city: Witu. In a very short time, a few stone buildings - such as a patrician house (the "palace" of the sultan) and a mosque - were erected in the town and the latter was encircled by a stockade. By examining the case of Witu, I analyse how the urban legacies of a city were used in order to re-constitute political power and, more generally, how authority was staged in Swahili urban spaces.

Re-Reading the Precolonial City. Antananarivo in the 19th Century

Author: Didier Nativel (Paris Diderot Paris 7 University)  email

Short Abstract

The city of Antananarivo witnessed a fast and profound transformation during the 19th century. The capital of an expanding kingdom which was connected both to the Mascarenes and to Europe, it became a laboratory of aesthetic, material and social change, which will be analysed by this paper.

Long Abstract

During the 19th century, Antananarivo was the capital of the main Malagasy kingdom, recognized by Western powers. In a few decades, the urban landscape translated deep political changes, becoming more and more distinct from the surrounding rural space. At the core of this cultural and spatial invention, local elites both linked to international trade networks and Christian missions, gradually adopted new ways of inhabiting and living the city from Mascarenes and Europe models. In this communication, I would like to address this material and social turning point, prior to the French colonization, discussing political, architectural and sensorial aspects of the issue.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.