List of panels

(P162)

Digipolities: conflict and media in Africa

Location C6.01
Date and Start Time 27 June, 2013 at 11:30

Convenors

Inge Brinkman (African Studies Centre) email
Koenraad Stroeken (Ghent University) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

In this panel we invite papers on comparative, interdisciplinary research in African contexts, that deal with various types of conflict (sudden political upheaval as well as long-term warfare) and look into the role of media and social hierarchies in changing communication patterns therein.

Long Abstract

Conflict in Africa has often been described in terms of ethnicity, world politics (the Cold War) or economic resources. Recently a new explanation has been offered: communication patterns as a factor in conflict and war. Communication may accelerate and/or mediate conflict. The sharp increase in mobile phone use in Africa and the rise of social media have triggered discussions on communication, political action and conflict worldwide.

In this panel we will contribute to these debates by hosting papers on comparative, interdisciplinary research in various African contexts. We will compare various types of conflict (sudden political upheaval versus long-term warfare) and look into the role of media and social hierarchies in the changing communication patterns.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

Communicating war: the Mali conflict in a changing communication landscape

Authors: Mirjam de Bruijn (Institute of History)  email
Lotte Pelckmans (Leiden University (Institute of History))  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

The analysis of the present Mali conflict shows how media -especially social media and mobile phones- have become part and parcel of ‘warfare’ as a social process.

Long Abstract

News about the Mali conflict in 2012 came first through the communication of a person in Paris, next was the website of one of the main 'movements', and third were the phone calls we received of friends from Northern Mali, called Azawad, or 'occupied zone' depending on the actors, who range from Tuareg rebels, Islamists, the Malian government to the international community. Facebook pages where news on the situation was exchanged, united people from Azawad, Bamako, USA and Europe. A similar situation in the 1990's, when the North of Mali was also under rebellion, did not have such exposure and there was hardly communication with the outside world. What has happened in the period between 1990 and 2012 that can explain these changes? What has been the role of communication technology 'revolution' in the region? Douentza (southern Azawad) received its first wireless spot in 2002, other towns in the North (Boni, Tombouctou, Kidal) were connected from 2005 onwards. How did this connectivity impact on the manifestation of the conflict in the international world? Is there a relation between the development of the conflict and its mediation? This paper is based on empirical research in Northern Mali during various periods between 1990 and 2013, including two field visits to South Azawad, and internet and media screening of the conflicts' development.

These empirical data will help to understand how media -especially social media and mobile phones- have become part and parcel of 'warfare' as a social process.

Media, innovation and political conflict in Somalia

Authors: Nicole Stremlau (University of Oxford)  email
Iginio Gagliardone (University of Oxford)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Media have had a central role in the ongoing violence in South Central Somalia. This paper explores how state and non-state actors have sought to use a variety of old and new communication technologies to consolidate power and promote competing political agendas.

Long Abstract

The absence of a functioning state in parts of Somalia has not prevented the diffusion of new communication technologies or traditional mass media such as radio. On the contrary, it can be argued that the absence of institutions controlling and regulating the communicative space has facilitated their spread. There is intense competition between telecom companies that provide mobile and internet services, offering some of the lowest rates on the continent. Dozens of radio stations broadcast across Somalia and there is a competitive newspaper industry in Somaliland.

This paper explores the role of media in Somalia and examines how media have been used in political conflict and violence. It also examines the ways in which media have been regulated in the absence of formal laws or in the situations characterized by the lack of ability to implement and enforce law which are common in South Central Somalia or in Somaliland where legal frameworks do exist. By considering how conflicts between media outlets and the state, or individuals, have been resolved outside of a formal court system, sometimes using customary law (xeer), insight into the relationship between media and public authorities is probed. The paper concludes by reflecting on conflict and post-conflict media policy making, and the relevance and potential impact of such efforts, by discussing current efforts by the government in South Central Somalia to implement media and telecommunications legislation.

To rebel or to march for freedom? Explaining the use of violent or non-violent protest strategies of self-determination movements by reference to framing

Author: Anne Theobald (University of Tuebingen)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

While some self-determination movements in Sub-Saharan Africa rebel to obtain secession, others pursue their objective non-violently despite similar circumstances. This paper aims at explaining this variation in behaviour by analysing communication processes of movements with the help of framing.

Long Abstract

Sub-Saharan Africa has recently experienced a rise of self-determination movements. This does not seem surprising as borders are arbitrary and internally contested due to colonial rule. Resulting ethnic diversity can easily be instrumentalised to mobilise combatants. Furthermore, there are opportunities for violent struggle due to weak state capacity and the availability of small arms. Hence, one could deduce that the continent is especially affected by armed conflict over secession. However, violent secessionist conflicts in Sub-Sahara Africa were - and still are - scarce. Instead, in many instances social movements seek self-determination through non-violent strategies.

This paper aims to elucidate why some African self-determination movements choose non-violent collective action, while others claim secession through violent rebellion despite similar circumstances. Prevailing theories on violent conflict cannot explain this variation in collective behaviour. Thus, the paper will integrate the framing approach into conflict studies. Framing focuses on communication processes within social movements. It reveals how movements interpret and construct their environment, how they diffuse their message and calls to action, how this translates into specific strategies of mobilisation, and finally - violent or non-violent - action. The framing approach will be applied to a most-similar case study design, which compares self-determination movements in the cases of Senegal and Zambia that adopted violent and non-violent strategies, respectively.

Not only does this approach help to identify micro-mechanisms explaining the escalation of violence, but it also yields insights into communication processes and internal dynamics of protest movements as well as their strategic interaction with their environment.

Media and afflictive identity in post-conflict Uganda

Author: Karin van Bemmel (Ghent University)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

This qualitative study compares the discourse of affected families, health workers and politicians (during five months of fieldwork in northern Uganda) with media conceptualization of Nodding Syndrome.

Long Abstract

Media and afflictive identity in post-conflict Uganda

Nodding Syndrome (NS) is an unknown affliction which has been reported to affect thousands of children in post-conflict northern Uganda, South Sudan and in Tanzania.

This qualitative study compares the discourse of affected families, health workers and politicians (during five months of fieldwork in northern Uganda) with media conceptualization (based on available mediatised reports and newspaper articles). Focus is put on how meanings of key terms related to Nodding Syndrome are produced and negotiated. Attention is being paid to the circulation of different discourses and explanatory models with a clear divide between hegemonic biomedical accounts and counter-hegemonic social-issue analyses. We argue that NS is an instance of afflictive identity obliquely recounting a people's political history.

The moral economy of social media in eastern and southern Africa: a comparative analysis

Authors: Koenraad Stroeken (Ghent University)  email
Sigurd D'hondt (Ghent University)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

We seek to elicit the discursive modes and codes in conflict-preventive, crowd-sourcing social media, comparing data on initiatives in Kenya (Ushahidi), Tanzania (a.o., Mzumbe U) and South Africa (a.o. UWC).

Long Abstract

Given Garfinkel's position that sensemaking is essentially a moral phenomenon, we look into how information technologies impact on people's accountability frameworks and how mobile communication (e.g. via cell phones) alters the moral landscape of users. The evidence on which we draw is collected from Ushahidi ('testimony' in Kiswahili), an open source project that allows users to 'crowdsource' crisis information sent via mobile. The project is an internet-based initiative that started in the aftermath of Kenya's disputed 2007 presidential election. An application was developed that (1) enabled local observers to submit reports of violence using their mobile phones (text message) or the internet (email) and (2) brought together these eyewitness reports on Google Maps, thus creating a temporal and geospatial record of acts of violence. Soon thereafter, similar sites were set up for other regions affected by crisis and civil war. We seek to elicit the discursive modes and codes, adding and comparing data on initiatives in Tanzania (a.o., Mzumbe U) and South Africa (a.o. UWC).

Arab revolutions and Spanish women journalists: a feminized communication pattern of the conflicts in Tunisia and Libya?

Author: Carmen Vidal Valiña (Universidad Complutense De Madrid, Spain)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

In this paper, I will analyze the coverage of the female Spanish women journalists about the conflicts in Tunisia and Lybia, to search speciffic features that will allow us to speak of a differentiated feminized patern in the way of approaching to this reality, compared to the one of their male counterparts.

Long Abstract

The conflicts in Tunisia and Lybia produced a great interest in the Spanish audience. In the coverage of the public television, TVE, a great number of women journalists were sent to these two countries. They were young, without not a great experience on the field and not specialized on the Arab-Islamic world. Their profile was, then, very different from the one of their male counterparts. But, did they use their gender to get into the lives of local women? Did they pay special attention to some topics normally not considered by men? To sum up: did they change the communication patterns about the Arab revolutions if we compare them with the work of the Spanish male journalists? And, in addition to these questions: what did they job offer as new elements to the Spanish audience?

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.